Order a Cookie Now - You Deserve It

We make fresh, delicious cookies in Buffalo, NY

Wondering where you can find freshly baked cookies in Buffalo, NY? You've come to the right place! Here at Heavenly Little Bites LLC, we've got classic flavors like chocolate chip and unbelievable specialty flavors like pineapple upside down and key lime pie. Call 716-226-8802 to order a cookie now!

Want to create your own personal cookie? You can become the ultimate Cookie Boss. To place a cookie order, just pick your base dough, then add up to five of your favorite mix-ins. Our base dough options include original, sugar, oatmeal and chocolate.

Ready to order a cookie now? Cookie orders will be available for pickup or delivery within 10 miles of our bake shop.

What's your favorite flavor?

Our awesome cookie flavors include...

Classic:

Chocolate chip walnut | Oatmeal raisin | Oatmeal butterscotch | Peanut butter | Mexican wedding cake

Specialty:

Banana pudding | Peach cobbler (not available for shipping) | Pot o' gold | Pineapple upside down | German chocolate | Birthday cake | Sugar | Strawberry shortcake | Vegan chocolate chip | White chocolate macadamia nut | Key lime pie | Red velvet | Carrot cake

Place a cookie order today - you won't regret it!

Menu

Original 6

Chocolate chip Cookies

36.00

Each order contains a dozen delicious, rich, buttery cookies, loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips and ooey, gooey chocolate chunks. Each Cookie is individually packaged for easy sharing or not, no judgement!

Ingredients: Butter, flour, semi sweet chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, sugar, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, baking soda, and salt.

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

36.00

Each order contains a dozen of delicious chewy raisiny goodness. These cookies are the favorite of many. Loaded with plump sweet raisins and laced with spices. Chewy in the center and slightly crispy edges make for the perfect cookie to accompany an iced cold glass of milk.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, semi sweet chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, walnuts, sugar, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, baking soda, and salt.

Mexican Wedding Cake Cookies

36.00

Perhaps the official cookie of Christmas, available all year long, We hand chop fresh pecans and marry them with our sweet, buttery dough. This cookie bakes to a slight crunch, then is tossed in confectioners powdered sugar right out the oven, once they are cooled they are tossed 2 more times. They are popular across many cultures and have taken names accordingly; Russian tea cakes , and snowball cookies. Each order receives 3 dozen cookies, wrapped in sets of 3.

Ingredients: Butter, Flour, Conf

Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies

36.00

Everything good that our chocolate chip cookies offer with the addition of walnuts for extra texture and depth of flavor. They are so good, you won't want to stop eating them.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, semi sweet chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, walnuts, sugar, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, baking soda, and salt.

Oatmeal Butterscotch Cookies

36.00

Soft, chewy, and delicious oatmeal cookies are perfect at any time. Add butterscotch morsels for a plot twist and your tastebuds are in for an adventure! There is no doubt about it, these are one of our top sellers. Locals playful call them "crack cookies" and they are not wrong. They are truly addictive. If you have a sweet tooth this is the cookie for you.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, oatmeal, butterscotch morsels, brown sugar, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, baking soda, salt.

Peanut Butter Cookies

36.00

To all my peanut butter lovers this is for you. Soft, chewy, and full of peanut butter. This cookie is surprisingly does not contain any flour! Peanut butter, eggs, sugar and flavoring, that's it! Be careful, you may find yourself eating the whole dozen.

Ingredients: peanut butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract

Specialty Cookies

Peach Cobbler Cookies

45.00

All the amazing flavors of peach cobbler in a delicious cookie. This cookie is a labor of love. We started with our original oatmeal base added some peach schnapps and diced peaches for a little extra flavor punch. Then we did the unthinkable, created a peach cobbler mixture full of spices, brown sugar, vanilla, spices, butter and peach bourbon and put a scoop right in the center. We then drizzled it with a peach bourbon glaze.

Ingredients: butter, oatmeal, brown sugar, granulated sugar, peaches

Red Velvet Cookies

45.00

Red Velvet cake is popular in the south. We took all of those flavors and put it into a cookie. Chocolate, buttermilk and lots of red coloring make this cookie scream "Southern treat". Then we added chocolate chunks, white chocolate chips, milk chocolate chips and it's a hit.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, brown sugar, milk chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, white chocolate chips, eggs, and vanilla extract

Banana Pudding Cookies

45.00

We love banana pudding and sometimes you want to take it with you without worrying about having a refrigerator. This cookie is all the greatness of banana pudding in a cookie. We took our original cookie batter and added fresh bananas, banana pudding, white chocolate chips, and vanilla wafers. We baked them to a perfection and the banana pudding cookie was born.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, banana, white chocolate chips, banana pudding , eggs, vanilla wafers, baking soda, vanilla extract.

German Chocolate Cookies

45.00

German chocolate cake just like Grandma used to make in a cookie. We started with a chocolate cookie batter and upped the ante. A rich buttery coconut, pecan frosting topped this cookie and was drizzled with dark chocolate,

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, brown sugar, , pecans, coconut, condensed milk, eggs, vanilla extract.

Birthday Cake Sugar Cookies

45.00

A party waiting to happen. We took our sugar cookie and made it taste like birthday cake! We mixed in lots of sprinkles, and topped it with icing and more sprinkles to create this fun cookie. Kids love it or those young at heart.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, sprinkles, eggs, vanilla extract and other flavoring.

Key Lime Pie Cookies

45.00

We love turning your favorite desserts into cookies! This Key lime pie cookie is no exception. This cookie begins with our sugar cookie recipe and adds key lime juice, graham crackers, and lots of key lime zest. Then we topped it with a key lime glaze and the perfect amount of sweet and tart make this cookie a treat.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, eggs, key lime , baking soda, vanilla extract

Sugar Cookies

45.00

Soft, and chewy is how we would describe this cookie. This cookie is simple yet so complex. We started with our sugar cookie recipe and topped with candy coated chocolate pieces.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, brown sugar, banana, white chocolate chips, banana pudding , eggs, vanilla wafers, baking soda, vanilla extract

Lemon Meringue Cookies

45.00

We are at it again! All the flavor of Lemon Merigue pie in a cookie. We started with our sugar cookie recipe and added lemon juice, lemon zest and baked to pure perfection. We topped it with our lemon curd and a little merigue to finish it off. Summer time in a cookie!

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, eggs, lemons, baking soda and vanilla extract

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie

45.00

Chocolate & peanut butter, can you think of any other perfect combination? Chocolate Cookie dough with peanut butter chips, chocolate chunks, and milk chocolate chips, candy coated peanut butter candy, and a peanut butter drizzle, make this a decadent treat.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, sugar, cocoa, eggs, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, chocolate chips and chunks, candy coated peanut buter chips, baking soda and vanilla extract.

Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie

45.00

All of the flavor with none of the stuff you don't want! Flour, sugar, coconut milk, applesauce, organic coconut oil, and organic vegan chocolate chips, These cookies surprise you because you wouldn't have any idea that they are vegan. They are just that good!

Ingredients: Flour, sugar, coconut oil, coconut milk, applesauce, vegan chocolate chips, baking soda and vanilla extract.

Karema's Kitchen Sugar Free Chocolate Chip Cookies

45.00

Our sugar free cookie base made with butter, flour, truvia, and eggs. We throw in sugar free chocolate chips, and sugar free chocolate chunks and you have an amazing cookie with all the flavor and no sugar.

Ingredients: Butter, flour, truvia, sugar free chocolate chips and chunks, eggs and vanilla extract.

Karema's Kitchen Sink

45.00

This cookie started with an oatmeal base and we tossed in chocolate chips, raisins, pecans, and coconut! This cookie is fun and includes everything but the kitchen sink! The only thing needed is an ice cold glass of milk.
Ingredients: Butter, flour, oatmeal, brown sugar, sugar, chocolate chips, pecans, raisins, coconut, eggs, baking soda and vanilla extract.